DNA: The Last Biometric

DNA:
The Last
Biometric

The integrity of the U.S. immigration system rests in the Department of Homeland Security’s ability to positively identify known and unknown individuals throughout the travel continuum. The travel continuum begins with the visa application process and continues through arrival at Ports of Entry, application for immigration benefits, investigation and removal of immigration offenders and exit from the host country. Collection of biometric information such as fingerprints, iris, and facial images has vastly improved the efficiency and accuracy of this often arduous identification process.

Moving Beyond Fingerprints

When the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) launched its US-VISIT program in 2003, it opted to use fingerprint biometrics to establish the identities of foreign nationals entering the U.S. It has since biometrically enrolled nearly 100 million foreign nationals. In this context, collection of fingerprints from foreign nationals has proven to facilitate legitimate travel while also enabling immigration officers to focus on potentially dangerous or threatening individuals.

The fingerprint alone, however, may not always offer sufficient information to establish an individual’s identity in an immigration and border management context. Some visa categories, for example, require applicants to establish biological relationships to sponsors in the U.S. In other cases, Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents may encounter foreign nationals with possible links to crime, but discover there are no latent fingerprints (i.e., the impression left by finger ridges invisible to the naked eye that is often found at the scene of a crime) on file with which to positively identify these suspected foreign criminals. Law enforcement authorities often use latent fingerprints to prosecute suspected criminals.

The fact that fingerprints alone may not fulfill the mission needs of DHS components operating in these particular circumstances has lead many experts to question the value of the use of biometrics. While these vulnerabilities may exist, it is important to note there are biometric complements to the fingerprint. DNA, for example can both establish a familial relationship and place a person at a crime scene where no latent prints exist.

DNA use in a border management and immigration environment may initially seem excessive and perhaps even unjustified. However, as DHS mission needs and ‘in scope’ immigrant populations evolve, DNA use may emerge as viable biometric of the future.

Figure 1 depicts the adoption of biometrics (left to right) in the mission-critical function of verifying the identification of individuals throughout the travel continuum – both in the U.S. and other countries around the world.  Biometrics, such as fingerprints, facial recognition, and iris, are often used in combination to increase the accuracy of identifications.

Proven Use of DNA in the Immigration Environment

To reinforce the security, integrity and facility of the immigration system, DHS consistently researches emerging biometric identification technologies and their potential applications to identity management. One such biometric technology is DNA. Though some research suggests that because DNA testing is not an automated process, it is not a true biometric recognition system, both policy makers and scientists agree that the accuracy of DNA testing might result in future biometric applications.

DNA testing, in an ideal environment, requires at least four hours of processing. Always mindful of potential impacts to the efficiency of the immigration process, DHS recognizes that DNA testing is a viable option in limited benefits application cases where establishing biological relationships is a fundamental component of the adjudication process.

For example, the Priority Three Refugee Family Reunification Visa (P-3) requires applicants to demonstrate a biological relationship to a post-flight refugee legally residing in the U.S. After an eight month internal review of the P-3 application process, the Department of Figure 1 Biometrics enhance identity verification in a border management and homeland security context. DNA is an emerging biometric in this area.State and DHS jointly resolved to suspend applications to the P-3 visa category. A Department of State Fact Sheet, published in February 2009, concluded that in approximately 86 percent of the P-3 cases reviewed, individuals claiming to be family members either refused to take the DNA test or their DNA did not match that of their alleged relative.

In an effort to bolster the integrity of the immigration benefits system, DHS’ U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) anticipates continued collection of DNA from applicants where the Immigration Nationality Act (INA) requires that a legal relationship exist between the applicant and the US-based relative. Concerns surrounding applicant privacy, DNA database management and the integrity of overseas DNA testing centers will continue to affect adjudication outcomes in categories such as the P-3 Family Reunification Visa. While routine collection of DNA in a Port of Entry environment is unlikely due to processing constraints, it appears that DNA testing will continue to play a critical role in streamlining the immigration benefits process.

Could DNA Break the Code to Identity in Immigration Enforcement?

Future DNA use in a homeland security context may also extend to the immigration enforcement arena. In January 2009, the Department of Justice approved the collection of DNA samples from people arrested and detained for suspected immigration violations. Historically, immigration enforcement officers have collected fingerprints and photographs from suspected immigration offenders. However, as DNA studies demonstrate a 1-in-6-billion chance of two people having the same genetic profile, DNA might prove a valuable tool in prosecuting immigration violators with potential criminal histories.

DHS faces critical challenges as it seeks to minimize the compromise that often occurs between securing the nation and facilitating legitimate trade and travel. DNA has the potential to reduce visa processing times, prevent immigration fraud, and protect the U.S. borders and its interior when applied to an appropriate in-scope population and used in conjunction with more traditional biometric systems such as fingerprint, face recognition and iris.

 

Blog Border Security

Contributors

* Arc Aspicio | Arc Aspicio is an information technology and management consulting company that focuses on homeland security and intelligence. Our services include strategy and planning, business architecture, strategic communications, mission/technology alignment, information technology, and program management. Arc Aspicio is building a community that promotes collaboration, continuous learning, innovation, and intelligence to improve homeland security. For more information, please visit www.arcaspicio.com.

Contact Information
Lynn Ann Casey / Chief Executive Officer
info@arcaspicio.com
703.465.2060

Organization Redesign: Is the Cure Worse than the Ailment?

Organization Redesign: Is the Cure Worse than the Ailment?

According to a popular management joke, new executives should blame their predecessors when facing their first crisis.  When facing their second crisis, they should reorganize everything. Jokes are funny when they’re seen as plausible. Reorganizations show action, produce change, and create opportunities for new leadership. However, are reorganizations worth the disruption?

Arc Aspicio to Host Design Thinking Forum: Creating the Future of Government on June 21

Arc Aspicio to Host Design Thinking Forum: Creating the Future of Government on June 21

Washington, DC, June 7, 2017 — Arc Aspicio plans to host an inaugural Design Thinking Forum featuring a discussion on how Federal leaders can innovate solutions to create the future of Government. Design Thinking is a human-centered innovation process that emphasizes observation, collaboration, fast learning, visualization of ideas, rapid concept prototyping, and concurrent business analysis, which ultimately generates innovation and increased mission outcomes.

Firefighters Show You Can Develop a Strategy While Fighting Fires

Firefighters Show You Can Develop a Strategy While Fighting Fires

“Employees at all levels are too busy ‘doing their jobs’ and ‘fighting fires’ to devote time or pay heed to strategic initiatives.” It’s a common complaint. Academic literature has confirmed that ‘firefighting’ takes up much of the manager’s job and offers extensive advice on how to stop fighting fires – and even how to suppress the urge to do so.

The SILab: An Invitation to Embrace Innovation

The SILab: An Invitation to Embrace Innovation

Government agencies and businesses must embrace innovation and strategic thinking to keep up with today’s changing society, rising demands, and complex problems. Encouraging organizations to fully adopt innovative thinking, however, is difficult. Organizations are often focused on their daily activities and have limited time to discover new approaches. In addition, employees often choose to stay with proven, mainstream solutions because they fear wasting resources or failure. 

Putting the Mission First in a Leader’s Agency Reform Plan

Putting the Mission First in a Leader’s Agency Reform Plan

Agency leaders have more than a little to do these days. The Office of Management and Budget (OMB) released guidance for implementing Executive Orders and Presidential Memoranda on Federal management and human capital. The Comprehensive Plan for Reforming the Federal Government and Reducing the Federal Civilian Workforce (M-17-22) directs agencies to create comprehensive plans to enhance mission focus, streamline operations, and improve workforce effectiveness and efficiency.

SharePoint: Unique Solutions for Homeland Security Partners

SharePoint: Unique Solutions for Homeland Security Partners

As information sharing has become more common across local, state, and federal agencies, homeland security partners need tools to manage this critical data. SharePoint has emerged as an information sharing tool that can assist emergency managers, law enforcement agencies, and others across the homeland security enterprise with the sharing of sensitive data with internal and external partners, quickly and securely.

Managing Change Using a Maturity Model

Managing Change Using a Maturity Model

The pace of change is accelerating. Government agencies, and their employees, must find new ways to support their stakeholders and manage internal operations in the face of changing mission expectations and potential budget cuts. Guiding the workforce through the change is messy and challenging and is essential to successful implementation of innovative ideas, technologies, and processes. 

Lost in Translation No Longer: Data Translators Bridge the Gap to the Mission

Lost in Translation No Longer: Data Translators Bridge the Gap to the Mission

Two main types of problems can make it difficult to make data-driven decisions: technical and cultural. Technical difficulties could include data that is messy, incomplete, or split between different departments or components. Cultural factors might include a resistance to change, an environment that favors trusting your instincts, or a belief that things are fine the way they are. 

How to Use Data to Drive Employee Engagement

How to Use Data to Drive Employee Engagement

When it comes to retaining your workforce, one feature correlates to 87% increases in retention and 57% increases in employee effectiveness. It is not compensation. It is employee engagement. Engagement measures an employee’s emotional commitment to an organization and willingness to use discretionary effort to achieve organizational goals. In other words, engaged employees strive to exceed the status quo. 

A Leader’s Most Influential Tool: Gratitude

A Leader’s Most Influential Tool: Gratitude

Gratitude is one of a great leader’s most powerful tools. It creates positive energy among an organization and the sense of appreciation permeates through the work the collective group is performing. Influential leaders listen to the needs of their colleagues and express gratitude. This helps them bring out the potential in the people they lead and inspire them to achieve what is most important to them and to the project.

The Design Era of Project Management

The Design Era of Project Management

Project Management best practices and methods continue to evolve to address the biggest challenges Government agencies face in today’s market. The increased use of Agile and the move from traditional waterfall methodologies is fairly common in Information Technologies. Projects use Agile methods such as Scrum or Kanban, and organizations invest a lot of time and effort to make this cultural shift on projects.