Immigration Enforcement: Small Solutions Have a Big Impact

Immigration Enforcement: Small Solutions Have a Big Impact

A small group of 15 auditors at Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) may soon have a substantial impact on worksite compliance. ICE recently announced the creation of a new unit to help combat the employment of illegal aliens. The Employment Compliance Inspection Center complements the Obama administration’s strategy of investigating employer violations of illegal hiring by analyzing I-9 and tax data of large companies suspected of violations to help ICE field offices pinpoint cases to pursue. ICE has announced plans to audit the records of approximately 1,000 businesses in the coming months. This program will complement the operational employment verification programs (e.g., U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) E-Verify) and investigative compliance programs across the Department.

This approach is, in part, a response to criticism that local field offices did not have the manpower or tools to investigate larger companies and that ICE has predominantly brought recent cases against smaller businesses. It further supplements the primarily voluntary employment verification programs (e.g., E-Verify, ICE IMAGE) by giving the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) the data to support stricter compliance actions against businesses who fail to meet established standards.

As with any new enforcement and compliance tool, there is backlash from the private sector. They are already raising complaints that these investigations are invasive and unfairly take advantage of businesses who believe they are in compliance, but still have illegal workers on their books. Subsequent corrective action could result in immediate termination of portions of the employer’s workforce and/or the leveeing of fines, both having a negative impact on the company’s production and financial viability. Furthermore, some have expressed concerns that given the current Federal budget crisis, this is not the right time or place to expend limited resources (e.g., estimates say the team will cost $1M in the first year).

ICE should continue to use all available tools at its disposal to combat illegal hiring. Using inspection and monitoring tools to drive companies to engage with compliance programs enhances DHS’s ability to enforce the immigration laws already on the books. The benefits of this and similar programs not only outweigh the negatives, but also provide value in other areas:

  • Increases the leveeing and collection of fines associated with these violations. In 2010, employers paid nearly $7M, a seven-fold increase in fines from the year before. With the additional audits, collections could reach $25M in the next year. These funds would not only pay for the unit itself, but also support other mission areas. Examples of this model exist within DoJ and Health and Human Services.  Their compliance task forces successfully collect millions of dollars each year, which offset any costs of operating the units
  • Provides additional resources to enable DHS to expand it’s monitoring beyond the primarily voluntary employment verification programs
  • Identifies better data analysis techniques and applications that could support other mission needs. For example, E-Verify’s Monitoring & Compliance Branch could leverage lessons from ICE to automate its processes to more proactively pick up on new trends and behaviors
Immigration

Contributors

Barbara White |

Barb works at Arc Aspicio as the Chief Strategy Officer and has proven strength in planning and managing business and technology solutions for the government. She blends innovative strategic thinking and tactical implementation with an emphasis on transformation, information sharing, immigration and transportation security.

Mr. Roboto: Your Newest Coworker

Mr. Roboto: Your Newest Coworker

Could your next cubemate be a robot? Elon Musk, the Tesla and SpaceX founder, is building our future coworkers and forming a world filled with Artificial Intelligence (AI) that could “beat us in just about everything,” including our jobs. As Musk attempts to create a real-life iRobot, many advantages and a possible partnership arise with this future. How can the Government and Homeland Security prepare and welcome new technological advancements?

Data + Strategy: Using Data to Inform Agency Strategy

Data + Strategy: Using Data to Inform Agency Strategy

Understanding the types of data available, gaining access to the right data, and making sense of data are daunting tasks for most organizations as they develop a strategy to meet mission demands and enterprise-wide goals. Data is especially challenging for the Government, yet provides the opportunity for insight for leaders as they strategically move their agencies forward.

Workplace Morale is Going to the Dogs… Literally!

Workplace Morale is Going to the Dogs… Literally!

There are few greater feelings than a dog’s unconditional love. And some are finding that a dog’s love can help combat stress at work. Secretary Zinke of the Interior Department announced his intent for "Doggy Days" where he encouraged employees to bring their canine companions to work on designated days. More than 80 dogs arrived for first event and the overjoyed employees immediately scheduled the next.

Accelerating FITARA Compliance: Five Steps That Leaders Can Take Today

Accelerating FITARA Compliance: Five Steps That Leaders Can Take Today

Implementing change is not always easy, but it is always necessary. Federal agencies have been working to transform how they acquire and manage Federal information technology (IT). The Federal Information Technology Acquisition Reform Act (FITARA) in December 2014 has increased visibility into this transformation.Although FITARA enhances the authority and accountability of Chief Information Officers (CIOs) in reviewing and approving major IT investment projects, CIOs continue to look for new ways to implement best practices at their agencies.

Combating the Rise of Transnational Criminal Organizations

Combating the Rise of Transnational Criminal Organizations

Crime, corruption, and violence – particularly involving drug, human, and weapons trafficking – continue to increase at an alarming rate in the U.S. Transnational Criminal Organizations (TCOs) are a critical part of this trend and pose a serious and growing threat to homeland security – at our borders and beyond.U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) is at the tip of the spear to combat TCOs. With the context that the first goal in their Vision and Strategy 2020 Strategic Plan is Counter Terrorism and Transnational Crime, CBP is focusing on disrupting TCOs responsible for the cross-border trafficking of illegal drugs, humans, and guns.

Design Thinking: Putting the Citizen at the Heart of Lasting Change

Design Thinking: Putting the Citizen at the Heart of Lasting Change

For the past few decades, there has been a growing increase in the digital channels available to network with the Federal government. These channels have made it easier for the public to interact and elicit responses from elected officials.These growing interactions have increased expectations for Government to be more transparent and collaborative. From the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) to the Department of State (DOS), Design Thinking transformations have begun to develop and modernize programs to be more human-centered. Agencies and programs beholden to serve the public good should logically adopt a problem-solving mindset that places the individual at the heart of any lasting changes.

Using Behavioral Science to Improve Mission Outcomes

Using Behavioral Science to Improve Mission Outcomes

Although behavioral science has been studied and applied within academia for decades, recently the concept has emerged everywhere – from Silicon Valley tech giants such as Google and Uber, to various Government agencies including the Department of Education, the Department of Defense, and the Department of Agriculture.But defining and applying such a broad and sometimes-nebulous discipline can prove difficult. What exactly is behavioral science? How can the Government use the concepts and lessons learned effectively?

Crowdsourcing to Improve Security

Crowdsourcing to Improve Security

Many of us are familiar with the idea of crowdsourcing. Corporations and the Government both use crowdsourcing to generate data, raise awareness campaigns, and produce ideas. So, what if we used crowdsourcing to enhance our security and bridge communication gaps between the Government and American citizens at the same time?

Homeland Security Managers = Innovative Leaders

Homeland Security Managers = Innovative Leaders

The search for and implementation of innovative methods to protect the homeland should play an important role in homeland security managers’ approach to how they guide their organizations. Citizens expect government leaders to propose and implement organizational, acquisition, and personnel management practices that enhance our nation’s ability to prepare for and mitigate potential threats. They expect these to make them safer and the nation more secure.